A Brief Timeline of the Alternate History Fandom

The speculative fiction community is divided into unique sets of fandom. These fandoms are not just defined by what they like, but also how they speak and dress. Even the means of communication and where they congregate plays a role. So its not surprising that even a sub-genre like alternate history has a thriving, if small, community. What is unique about the alternate history fandom is that its size makes it so that it did not arise until a method of communication, namely the Internet, allowed for fans to congregate in significant numbers.

Now as far as I know, no one has done a serious study on this fandom, but I do know a little of the history of the group. In the spirit of what they like, I decided to present that history in a timeline format:

220px-Beneath-the-Planet- 70of-Apes1970s: Sometime during this decade, Robert B. Schmunk found a copy of Robert Silverberg’s The Gate of Worlds at the Idaho Falls Public Library. He will later claim it inspired him to create a bibliography of alternate history fiction.


1987: KW Jeter coins the term “steampunk” to explain SF works set in alternate versions of the Victorian era, giving a name to the close cousin of alternate history (although they are often not on speaking terms) that would become a popular aesthetic, as well as literary, movement.

1990s: According to future Sidewise founder, Steven H Silver, alternate history experiences a small “boom” in the middle of this decade, that although never took off, did see fans begin to connect more over their shared passions.

1991: The Usenet Alternate History List was first posted by Schmunk on to rec.arts.sf-lovers, listing 250 works of alternate history 220px-Clockwork_orangeA 71after a request to help find published works in the genre. Most of the original list of 250 items were provided by Evelyn C. Leeper.

1995: The newsgroup soc.history.what-if was created for showcasing and discussing alternate histories. In that same year the first web version of the “Usenet Alternate History List” was created. Eventually the list would become web-only.

1996: The Sidewise Awards for Alternate History are presented at this year’s Worldcon. Meanwhile in New Zealand, Andrew Smith invents Brithenig, a constructed language based on the premise that Latin replaced Celtic as the primarily language of Britain, creating the romance language of Brithenig.

1997: The  Usenet Alternate History List is converted into a website and renamed Uchronia: The Alternate History List. Elsewhere, Andrew Smith creates the Brithenig Project in an effort to explain how Brithenig came to be. It will eventually evolve into Ill Silent_running 72Bethisad, one of the longest running collaborative timelines on the Internet.

1998Island in the Sea of Time by SM Stirling is published. The initials of the title, ISOT, is eventually adopted as a slang term to mean a story where a person or place is transported to a different period of time.

1999: Alison Brooks coins the term “alien space bats” to criticize an alternate history regarding Operation Sea Lion and implausible alternate histories in general.

2000: Ian Montgomerie creates Alternatehistory.com, a directory and discussion forum for alternate history on the web. Eventually, people from usenet groups would begin immigrating there. In this same year, Chris Nuttall created Changing the Times, an online magazine of alternate history that anyone could submit their work 220px-DarkStarpost 74erfor inclusion.

2002: The constructed language of Wenedyk is created for Ill Bethisad, turning Polish into a romance language. Also this year, Alison Brooks passed away. Before her death she would later regret that “alien space bats” would evolve into a term used to describe a supernatural agency that created an alternate history.

2003: The first issue of Paradox: The Magazine of Historical and Speculative Fiction is published. Paradox featured short fiction stories with a historical setting and included many works of alternate history and related genres.

2004: Montgomerie updates AlternateHistory.com into a new format. The old directory is replaced solely by the discussion forum, which becomes the largest gathering of alternate history fans on the Internet.

The_Rocky_Horror_Picture_Show 752005: Wenedyk undergoes a major revision due to a better understanding of Latin and Slavic sound and grammar changes. Meanwhile, the Alternate History Wiki is created, a spiritual successor to Ill Bethisad, since many veteran contributors from there helped get it off the ground.

2006Changing the Times is temporarily replaced by a German porn site. After that issue is sorted out, Nuttall hands over the administration to David Atwell.

2007: Alternia, another alternate history discussion board, falls due to infighting among its members. AlternateHistory.com would have few challengers from here on out.

2009: On May 12, the last issue of Paradox is released after the magazine failed to raise the necessary funding to remain in print.

2010Alt Hista magazine for historical fiction and alternate 225px-Man_who_fell_to_earth_ver 761history edited by Mark Lord, follows in the footsteps of Paradox by publishing their first issue.

2011: Matt Mitrovich created Alternate History Weekly Update as a news and reviews source on alternate history fiction. (Hey, shut up! I think its important!)

2012: The Alternate History Hub is created by Cody Franklin on YouTube, currently the most viewed channel on that medium dedicated solely to alternate history.

2013: Steampunk is predicted to be the next big thing according to an IBM supercomputer, much to the chagrin of alternate history purists.

2014: Uchronia reports that it lists over 3200 works of alternate history fiction.

I am sure I missed some important moments in this fandom’s 220px-StarWarsMoviePoster1977history, so please feel free to share your thoughts in the comments. I am hoping to do a more serious study of the fandom in the near future, but this timeline is a good outline to begin with.

Please take a moment to support Amazing Stories with a one-time or recurring donation via Patreon. We rely on donations to keep the site going, and we need your financial support to continue quality coverage of the science fiction, fantasy, and horror genres as well as supply free stories weekly for your reading pleasure. https://www.patreon.com/amazingstoriesmag

Previous Article

Kick-starter Continues to be Used as a Publishing Strategy

Next Article

Loncon3: Arrival

You might be interested in …


  1. In the late 1980s and early 1990s, the now-defunct GEnie online network (a competitor of Compuserve and AOL) was arguably the place to go for online alternate history discussions. Quite a few major AH authors posted there along with a lot of other very knowledgeable people. Steve Stirling posted regularly, along with Harry Turtledove, Steven Barnes, Ali Nofi and a horde of others. I posted there with a degree of trepidation, feeling like an ant among elephants at first.

    I downloaded the transcripts before GEnie went belly up and sometimes go through them for items of AH history interest. I’ve found places where Steve Stirling toyed with the ideas that I’m pretty sure later became Island in the Sea of Time, Conquistador and The Sky People and where Harry Turtledove brainstormed ideas on the series where the south won and the North America ended up with an equivalent of World War I.

    Unfortunately, GE sold their online service and the new owners rapidly destroyed the online AH community there sometime in the early 1990s.

  2. Thank you for the article. Having this timeline better explains how this subgenre grew and the roots of steampunk. Now I’ll check some of the sites you’ve suggested and see just how many AltHis stories I’ve read over the years unaware of their classification.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.