They’ve redone Lost In Space again. Did they do a good job? Well, uh….

Figure 1 – Bill Mumy

I know I’m not the first Amazing columnist to review this, but let’s go anyway. You might recognize the face at left; it’s actor/musician Bill Mumy, who was one of the stars of the original 1965 TV series Lost In Space. The series—which started out as “serious” TV SF, was loosely based on the Gold Key comic Space Family Robinson (1962), which was itself loosely (extremely) based on the book Swiss Family Robinson, by Johann Wyss (1812). Mumy, who was born in Feb. 1954, was already a known actor by the time LiS aired.

Mumy made his first TV appearance at age 6 in the TV series National Velvet (not to be confused with the Liz Taylor movie); he went on to appear in numerous TV shows, like Alfred Hitchcock Presents, Going My Way, The Fugitive, and one of his most notorious roles in one of his three appearances in Rod Serling‘s The Twilight Zone: that of Anthony Fremont, the monstrous little boy in Serling’s adaptation of Jerome Bixby‘s “It’s a Good Life.” Born with extreme telekinetic, telepathic, and other mental abilities, seven-year-old Anthony terrorized a small town thrown into another, bleak dimension with his dictatorial, God-like ways.

Mumy went on to many more television appearances until he was tapped to play Will Robinson in the ensemble TV “sci-fi” drama (in those days, despite Rod Serling and other notable writers/producers, science fiction was not taken seriously; the term “sci-fi” was invented by Forrest J (“Forry”) Ackerman in an attempt to popularize the genre by hijacking “hi-fi” (enormously popular in the 1950s). The term is now used to cover real SF, fantasy, and anything non-mainstream.)

Lost In Space also had Guy Williams (known for playing Zorro) as John Robinson; June Lockhart (from Lassie) as Maureen Robinson; Angela Cartwright (The Danny Thomas Show) as Penny; Marta Kristen (who once co-starred with Mumy in an Alfred Hitchcock episode) as Judy; Mark Goddard (The Detective) as Major Don West; Jonathan Harris (The Third Man) as Dr. Zachary Smith; and Bob May (body) and Dick Tufeld (voice) as B-9, the Environmental control robot.

Figure 2 – Robot B-9 and Bill Mumy

The robot in the above picture with Bill Mumy/Will Robinson, is called B-9. Many people who aren’t SF fans confuse it with Robby the Robot from Forbidden Planet. Although Robby made an appearance on Lost in Space, he wasn’t the series regular. Both robots were designed by Robert Kinoshita, a screenwriter, designer and art director—and who also designed the robot Tobor for the film Tobor The Great!

Although the series started out as straight SF drama, it quickly devolved into what Irwin Allen-produced series (Voyage to the Bottom of the Sea, Land of the Giants, etc.) always did: a “monster-of-the-week” show. Although Dr. Smith, Harris’s character, had started out as a pure villain and enemy agent (he was responsible for the Jupiter II getting lost in space), he quickly became a campy foil for Will Robinson and his “best friend” the robot B-9 (key phrase, “Danger, Will Robinson!”), and that saved the show for a more humourous second season. The mainstays of the show at this point were Will, B-9, Dr. Smith and, off and on, Penny and her alien chimpanzee companion “Bloop.” Smith’s role as an enemy agent was quickly dropped. The third season tried, unsuccesfully, to reboot LiS as a dramatic series, but alas, its time was over and it was cancelled. It has remained a favourite memory for Baby Boomers, however.

Figure 3 – Lost In Space movie crew

Thirty years elapse and, in 1998, Hollywood—which is always more comfortable with something that has already made money—decides to revive the series as a film. Good news, you say? My honest reaction to it was “meh.” Figure 3 shows the new robot (center) with (left to right) Matt LeBlanc (Major Don West); Heather Graham (Judy) in back; can’t tell who in back, but could be Jared Harris as older Will Robinson or could be Gary Oldman as Dr. Smith; and William Hurt as John Robinson. The robot—which is destroyed at one point and later rebuilt and never, as far as I can remember, given a name—has the same actor, Dick Tufeld, as its voice. It also had Mimi Rogers as Maureen; Lacy Chabert as Penny; Jack Johnson as Will; and Jared Harris as older Will.

Although a number of the original series’ actors were given cameos, the script was a muddled mess involving time travel (lots of it), alien “spiders,” a CGI “cute” alien to replace the chimp (this one called “Blarp”), and a different dissident group that Dr. Smith is working for. The movie Will, while attempting to be a very intelligent kid as in the series, didn’t have Mumy’s screen presence or the kind of interaction with Dr. Smith and the robot as the series was famous for. The other actors, with the exception of Gary Oldman, were competent, but were not given great roles, in my opinion. Oldman, I believe, can simply not turn in a bad performance, even in a bad movie.

Figure 4 – New Lost in Space robot with Will Robinson

And that brings us to Netflix and 2018’s new TV series of the same name. I will try to review this without major spoilers, but it will be hard; please forgive me if I give away some plot points.

The time something like thirty years in the future (the original’s “future” was 1997!); I don’t remember if they gave a year or not for this one, but somewhere I read 2046. The Earth is polluted—in one flashback, the characters had to wear gas masks when going shopping. This apparently happened during the “Christmas Star” comet/asteroid crash which occurred a couple of years before the story begins. Earth is becoming uninhabitable as a consequence, so a fleet of Jupiter spacecraft, carrying Earth’s best and brightest, is attached to a mothership, the Resolute, and launched towards Alpha Centauri which, we find out, has at least one habitable planet. (They don’t say which Alpha Centauri star; according to Wikipedia, it’s a trinary system.) This mission will be the Resolute’s 24th mission.

Maureen Robinson (Molly Parker) is a “scientist” (as they point out numerous times); she has a Ph.D. in Aerospace Engineering, and has helped design the Resolute and the Jupiters. She is separated from John Robinson (Toby Stephens), a Marine who has been absent from the family for several years doing “crucial missions.” They have three children: Judy (Taylor Russell), from Maureen’s previous marriage, who is an 18-year-old medical doctor; Will (Maxwell Jenkins), a somewhat precocious 11-year-old; and Penny (Mina Sundwall), a pretty smart and self-possessed 16-year-old redhead.

All colonists must pass a set of extreme physical and mental tests; of all the Robinsons, only Will fails to pass when he freezes up during a high-altitude stress test. Maureen secretly and illegally arranges for his fail marks to be turned to pass marks. Also on the Resolute are Don West (Ignacio Serricchio), an engineer who is also a smuggler; and June Harris (Parker Posey—name composed from June Lockhart’s and Jonathan Harris’s) who we will talk about in a bit. Harris has been discovered to be passing as her sister and is being interrogated when—the Resolute uses some kind of warp drive; shortly after the ship uses it—there is an attack on the Resolute and she escapes, stealing Dr. Z. Smith’s jacket and I.D.; the Robinsons are in the Jupiter 2; “Smith” and West are in the Jupiter 18; we know a number of Jupiters escape, but we don’t know exactly how many—nor do we know what happens to the Resolute while they’re gone. The Jupiters crash-land on a planet that just happens to be below them and habitable.

There are the bare bones of the plot; over ten episodes we will find out more about the colonists’ attempts to escape the planet and return to the Resolute; we will meet the alien robot that becomes Will’s companion, and a lot more I won’t go into except in a small way. (The robot does get to say “Danger, Will Robinson” once or twice.)

I suspect that whether you like this series is dependent upon whether you saw and/or liked the original series; some of it is age-dependent. I make no secret that I’m a Baby Boomer and saw the original when it was new, but I have 30-ish friends who did not. Many of them, it appears, like this series—but for different reasons than I liked the original. Like me in the ‘60s, there doesn’t seem to be any attempt on their part to apply critical thinking to this series, or the scientific (even the pseudo-scientific for, let’s face it, most TV and movie SF uses technobabble or bolognium or even unobtainium for its science) basics espoused in it.

I won’t attempt to go into a whole lot of the scientific bushwah coming out of the TV for this series; we could start with the “Christmas star” being an extinction-level event that will make the Earth uninhabitable. I’m assuming they’re basing that on the Chicxulub asteroid that was a primary factor in the dinosaur extinction. As far as I know, that wasn’t a slow event—whether it was fire or ice (scientists argue for both) that hit the Earth that day, extinction was swift. And I don’t think the dinos would had a chance to build spaceships even if they could have.

Let’s move on to Will Robinson’s mom getting him on the ship by faking his test results. If it were that easy, the Jupiters would be full of billionaires; I can pretty much guarantee it. Let’s talk about “scientist” Maureen taking off her space helmet because John has a rip in his suit: “if the atmosphere was dangerous, you’d be dead already.” Uh, no… I can offhand think of any number of things that will kill you so slowly you don’t know you’re dying until it’s too late, not the least of which are germs and bacteria!

The whole show, in my opinion, is full of those sorts of things. If you are going to watch it, you need to turn off your brain and just watch in dull-eyed wonder at all the non-science fiction and enjoy the pretty lights in this “sci-fi” epic. The writing, by the way, is what my father used to call “slow as a wet weekend.” It drags, most of the time.

I have to mention Posey’s “Dr. Smith”—she tells everyone that her doctorate is in psychology; she uses that to get information on, and subtly influence, everyone in the show. She’s not a whiny, campy Smith like Jonathan Harris, she’s a person who will do or say anything that she thinks will guarantee her survival. She’s also one of the best actors on the show.

This Will Robinson is kind of wimpy compared to Mumy’s Will. He’s not brash or self-confident; he’s not as brainy, either, it appears. However, I have to say that the new Judy and Penny are a joy to watch. Judy’s not terribly self-confident as someone who was rushed through medical training, but Penny is confident as some teen girls are; both are strong young women who might actually carry this series farther than their namesakes did in the original.

So enjoy the show; it’s got enough sci-fi glitter to attract those who like “sci-fi” that’s not rigourous. I may even dip into the second season myself just to see what the Robinson girls and Dr. Smith are up to; but I’m afraid I can only give this series two out of five flibbets.

Comments? Compliments or brickbats? Let me have it. Comment here, or on my Facebook page, or in the other Facebook groups where this is linked. All your comments are welcome, pro or con! (Please don’t feel you have to agree with me to comment, either. Let me know what I did right or wrong.) My opinion is, as always, my own, and doesn’t necessarily reflect the views of Amazing Stories or its owner, editor, publisher or other columnists. See you next week!

Related articles


  1. Sorry for the nitpicking, but you cited the “Christmas Star” as an example of “scientific bushwah” based on what you “know”. In 2013, researchers from Berkeley and their European colleagues determined that the Chicxulub impactor struck the earth approximately 66 million years ago (their exact figure was accurate to within 11,000 years) and also determined that the mass extinction of dinosaurs was completed about 33,000 years later. In geological terms, this is considered practically “overnight”, but it’s actually a long time on a human technological scale. I wouldn’t fault the writers of Netflix’s Lost In Space for assuming that humans would have enough time to evacuate a small portion of the population to another planet following a similar impact. It’s actually a very interesting point in the show since Maureen Robinson thought it would take decades to develop an interstellar drive, but somehow a new kind is available and ready to be used.

    1. Thanks, Corey! I sit corrected. You don’t have to apologize to me for nitpicking; if I get something wrong, I need to know it.

  2. I stopped watching Blindspot after a half-dozen episodes. She has one expression and he has one different expression. Yes, the super-secret base of the DFO–which is what, “Department of Flying Objects”?–seems to be not much of a secret. And half of the city seems to know Kara is Supergirl.
    I only watch the show because she’s cute as hell. I try not to pay attention to the continuity, science (or lack thereof), or plot–which is likely to be soap-opera anyway.

  3. I really enjoyed the series on the basis of some fine acting by all involved and the twisty plots. It’s true I wish they did more than just play lip-service to some of the science, but at least they acknowledged that science was the only thing that could save them. I was worried that (not much of a spoiler here) an astronomical event that plays a part in the show was just too coincidental to be happening just at the time the Robinsons, et al, had crashed onto the planet. That concern was resolved in a convincing way.

    I also liked that the show gave all the characters something meaningful to do, and didn’t just focus on Will/the Robot/Dr. Smith. Judy was particularly compelling, and Taylor Russell does a great job playing her.

    It’s not a perfect show by any means, but I’d give it three out of four stars and I’m looking forward to a possible second season.

    1. Well, as always, Dave, it’s just my opinion. Lots of people either agree with me, disagree with me or just say “Steve who?” 🙂 Like you, I thought the young women, as well as “Dr. Smith,” were terrific. (Not just the writing, the acting as well.)

  4. Yet more television I have to just turn the brain off and not think about. And then there are the weird other errors that used to be caught by the continuity folks. Last night we caught up with BLINDSPOT. Part of the episode had Patterson go out on a date. See Patterson in the elevator with blue eyeliner on. See Patterson out on date WITH NO BLUE EYELINER. See Patterson back at FBI after explosion and gunfight while out on date with blue eyeliner back on. Stop DVR while son cackles about the case of the missing eyeliner. Meanwhile, back at SUPERGIRL, see the hidden super secret base get attacked again every few weeks. Think that, obviously, those good folks need a new super secret base.


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.